Homemade vs. Store-Bought Holiday Dog Treats
‘Tis the Season for Treats and Tail Wags!
Happy Holidays! Team Lord Jameson wishes you a very Happy Hanukkah, Merry Christmas and a splendid New Year!
The holidays aren’t just about family dinners and twinkling lights - they’re about sharing joy, and for pet parents, that includes our dogs. From the smell of fresh-baked cookies to the rustle of wrapping paper, our pups sense the excitement and want to be part of it all.
Unfortunately, most human foods aren’t best suited for our pups and furry friends. When it comes to festive dog treats, many pet parents wonder: Should I bake my own, or buy store-bought treats?
Both options can show your dog just how loved they are - but they’re not created equal. Let’s explore the pros and cons so you can make the best (and safest) choice this holiday season.
Making Dog Treats At Home
If you have baked homemade treats and cookies for your furry baby, you know how much of a heart-warming experience it can be. You also know how time and energy consuming it is.
Pet-parents often face the conundrum of offering your pet the best, healthiest and tastiest of the treats, but struggle with the time, energy and comfort part of the process.
The questions can feel overwhelming, especially when you are already under pressure of cleaning the house, completing the to-do list and finishing work before the holidays.
What feels like a celebratory moment can soon feel a bit much if the treats don't turn out the way we wanted, or the ingredients feel unhealthy or safe.
You can make it easier, and still ensure your pup enjoys the holidays with Lord Jameson, you can still know you are getting a mouth-watering, healthy and celebratory experience for your beloved.
The Convenience and Safety of Store-Bought Treats
These days, store-bought treats fill aisles, often confusing the pet-parents about which one is the best option. The options are never-ending!
High-quality, store-bought treats, especially organic and vet-approved ones, can be both safe and delicious for your dog. Just as research highlights how organic and plant-based foods support better health for humans, similar findings reveal that natural, organic diets can offer the same wellness benefits for dogs too.
Modern pet treat makers, like Lord Jameson, consciously focus on using clean, functional ingredients that taste great while supporting your dog’s health.
Benefits of Store-Bought Treats:
-
Safety-tested: Professionally formulated for canine digestion and nutrition.
-
Longer shelf life: Great for busy pet parents who want ready-to-use rewards.
-
Consistent quality: Every treat delivers the same taste and texture.
-
Convenient gifting: Perfect for holiday stockings or sharing with fellow dog parents.
Of course, not all store-bought treats are created equal. Some contain preservatives, artificial flavours, and fillers that can do more harm than good. Always check the ingredient list for wholesome, natural ingredients you recognise, especially if your pet has allergies or health issues.
The Sweet Spot: Choosing the Best of Both Worlds
For many pet parents, the perfect balance lies in choosing organic, human-grade store-bought treats that offer homemade quality without the guesswork.
At Lord Jameson, we believe in spreading holiday joy through organic, plant-based treats made with real ingredients, like oats, coconuts, peanut butter, and seasonal fruits. Our recipes are USDA Organic Certified, preservative-free, and crafted in small batches right here in the USA.
Whether you’re filling your dog’s stocking with Christmas Gingerbread, Candy Cane Kisses, or Hanukkah Gelt, each bite delivers a burst of holiday cheer, safely and deliciously.
How to Make the Right Choice for Your Dog?
Here are a few quick tips when deciding between homemade and store-bought holiday treats:
1. Read ingredient labels carefully. Avoid artificial colors, preservatives, and fillers.
2. Stick to organic ingredients. Clean, plant-based recipes are easier on sensitive stomachs.
3. Watch portion sizes. Even healthy treats should be enjoyed in moderation.
4. Introduce new treats gradually. Prevent tummy upsets during the holidays.
5. Make it special. Our pets don’t care if the treat comes from the oven, or a store. They want to celebrate with us, play with us, go on walks and meet human and other furry friends.
And most importantly, have that soft, chewy and crunchy treat of goodness when their humans have their special meals!
We recommend checking with your veterinarian if you’re unsure about the right treats, how to switch them safely, or what allergy signs to watch for.
A Holiday Cheer from Lord Jameson
This season, celebrate your pup with treats that are as pure and joyful as their love for you. With Lord Jameson’s holiday collection, you can skip the baking mess, skip the guesswork, and simply share the spirit of the season, one tail wag at a time.
Because no matter how you serve it, love (and healthy, delicious, natural goodness) is the secret ingredient in every perfect holiday treat! Happy Holidays!
